Why your interview stories are boring (and how to fix them)
Learn how to add tension, show judgment, and tell stories interviewers remember.
Most engineers walk into interviews knowing they should “tell stories.” But what they actually deliver is a project recap — a sequence of events with no real tension, no stakes, and no sense that anything meaningful hung in the balance.
It’s not that they lack interesting experiences. They’re just removing the parts that make the story work.
When you strip out the uncertainty, the risk, and the moment where things could have gone sideways, the story goes flat. Interviewers tune out because there’s nothing to latch onto, no decision point, no pressure, no visible judgment.
Here’s how to tell stories that actually land.
Your stories are boring because nothing is at risk
In real engineering work, the decisions that matter are the ones where something’s on the line — a deadline, a partner relationship, a system’s stability, a team’s trust. But most candidates leave this out. They summarize the situation as if the entire experience were obvious in hindsight.
The tension is what interviewers want to hear, because tension reveals judgment:
- What you noticed
- What worried you
- What you weighed
- What you chose and why
If everything in your story feels inevitable and straightforward, the interviewer learns nothing about how you think.
Add clear stakes so the interviewer cares
A compelling story doesn’t need chaos or heroics. It just needs clarity about why this moment mattered.
Instead of saying, “Testing took longer than we expected,” say what was actually at risk, like a delayed release, customer impact, or a dependency blocking another team.
Instead of “We disagreed about the design,” explain why the disagreement mattered — performance tradeoffs, scalability issues, maintenance costs, or how the team handled ambiguity.
A great interview story makes the listener understand that if this went wrong, something meaningful would have happened.
You’re including the wrong details
Engineers love context. Sometimes too much. The only details that matter are the ones that move the story toward its decision point.
Ask yourself:
- Does this detail help clarify the stakes?
- Does it set up the moment where I had to make a judgment call?
- Does it give the interviewer the context they need to understand my choice?
If not, cut it. Your story gets sharper the moment you remove everything that doesn’t pull its weight.
Highlight the moment things could have gone wrong
This is the missing piece in most stories: the point where you weren’t sure what would happen next.
This is where your judgment becomes visible. Interviewers want to know:
- What options you considered
- What tradeoffs you recognized
- What risks you flagged
- What constraints shaped your thinking
If you skip this part, you’re skipping the reason the interviewer asked for the story in the first place.
Stories resonate when the interviewer can see you making an informed choice under uncertainty. That’s the senior signal.
Resolve the story — and explain what changed afterward
A story needs a clean ending. Explain:
- What happened
- What you learned
- What permanent adjustment you made to your workflow or communication
That last part is often the most important. It tells the interviewer you didn’t just survive the situation, you improved because of it. You built a new habit, a new guardrail, or a new way of noticing problems.
This is what separates “someone who got through it” from “someone who leads through it.”
A structure that keeps your story focused and engaging
Use this when preparing stories for behavioral or hiring manager interviews:
- Set the context. Who was involved and why this moment mattered.
- Define the stakes. What could have gone wrong and why it was meaningful.
- Show the conflict. The tension, uncertainty, or complication you had to navigate.
- Reveal your judgment. What you chose and what informed that decision.
- Close with evolution. What happened and how your approach changed afterward.
This structure keeps the story tight, relevant, and grounded in your actual operating system as an engineer.
Level up with Formation
The Formation Fellowship gives mid-level and senior engineering job seekers everything they need to land their dream roles — including personalized skill brush-ups, resume help, unlimited mock interviews with experienced software engineers and hiring managers from top-tier tech companies, career and negotiation support, and more.
If you’re having trouble navigating your job search on your own, apply here and get unconditional support from a team of engineering mentors, technical recruiters, career coaches, and more.
